Wednesday, October 12, 2022

Good Questions

Prowling the stacks at Wonder Books, I stumbled across Ted Kerasote’s book Pukka‘s Promise: The Quest for Longer-Lived Dogs. The title is pretty bad (hint: don’t put your dog’s name in the title of a book, because no one cares about your dog), but the topic is of considerable interest to me, as it’s the kind of stuff I’ve been writing about for several decades. 

From the flap: 

In an adventure that echoes ‘The Omnivore’s Dilemma’ with a canine spin, Kerasote tackles all those subjects questioning our conventional wisdom and emerging with new vital information that will surprise even the most knowledgeable dog lovers. Can a purebred be as healthy as a mixed-breed? How many vaccines are too many? Should we rethink spaying and neutering? Is raw food really healthier than kibble, and should your dog be chewing more bones? Traveling the world and interviewing breeders veterinarians and leaders of the animal welfare movement, Kerasote pulls together the latest research to help us rethink the every day choices we make for our companions.

A quick flip through the book
finds a lot of this is wind-up to a pitch. And that’s OK — I’m not lazy — but I find a lot of other people are lazy, and that hiding the gold in too much dirt means a lot of folks will walk past it and miss it. 

As for the title, it’s probably best to come at the reader about their concerns — avoiding canine expense and heartache — rather than hide that promise in cryptic alliteration. 

With that said, let’s see what gold can be panned out of this book.  No doubt there is gold — there are flecks right there in the flap.

2 comments:

Richard Gilbert said...

I felt the book was undercut by Kerasote's letting his dog run free. Pukka was allowed to go into the nearby village as well as roam the wild. Kerasote has a notion here that this makes for a better dog and gives it a better life.

Well, I detest free roaming dogs. Accidents happen, but as a policy it makes poor sense. He's not only sentimental but selfish.

Viatecio said...

I read it when it first came out and remember it being halfway decent.

I can't really support his notion to let his intact male dog free-roam around his town (might be realistic for HIS locale, but certainly not the ideal for the average citybound pet dog), but his conclusions aren't all wrong either.

Maybe one day I'll go through it again.