Friday, April 09, 2010
Pharoahs and Fantasy
Lot of dog types were depicted on Egyptian tombs! source
The Egyptians mummified scores of thousands of animals, including many dogs.
When we look inside these ancient mummies, however, what do we find?
Not Kennel Club ribbons!
Instead, we find pariah dogs almost identical to those found lounging around the pyramids of Egypt today.
Mummified dog, Egyptian Museum, Cairo.
Pariah dogs resting at the Saqqara Step Pyramid at Djsor.
Why is that?
Simple: the Egypt of today is not so very different from the Egypt of 4,000 years ago.
Around the world, landrace dog types are shaped by land and function. So long as land and function stay the same, landrace breeds will tend to maintain a certain level of "variable integrity" within a broad type.
Dog on the fly whisk of King Tutankhamen.
Of course different types have different functions, and some things (such as leg length and body size) are more important than others (such as ear type and tail set).
In flat country, where larger quarry can be coursed over open ground, a larger running dog is commonly found, while in thick forest, smaller animals may be hunted with dogs that are no bigger than terriers.
In more populated urban areas, heavier guard and pulling dogs may be more common, while on grazing lands stock-herding dogs may be the rule.
Coat length, of course, will tend to lengthen or shorten depending on weather.
Of course broad types of landrace pariah dogs of no particular breed are not the story Kennel Club enthusiasts want to tell when they look at the paintings on Egyptian tombs.
Where's the fun in that?
And so, we find Dalmatian owners pointing at any spotted dog as "proof" that their dog has an ancient provenance, while Corgi and Dachshund owners point to any short-legged achondroplastic dog as "proof" their dog also has an ancient and royal lineage.
And then, of course, there are the Basenji enthusiasts who proudly proclaim any dog with prick ears and a curly tail to be a Basenji, and never mind that such dogs have existed the world over since the beginning of time.
Look at the bas-relief below, from the tombs at Saqqara, for example. We are told this is a "Basenji" simply because it has a curly tail and prick ears. But do you notice a problem? This collar-wearing dog is taking down an Oryx, a type of gazelle which can weigh more than 200 pounds. That's quite an impressive feat for a "Basenji" that stands just 15" tall and which might weigh all of 25 pounds!
Of course there is another problem; the dog did not move from south to north in Africa, but from north to south. So if there were ever Basenji-like dogs in Egypt, then that is where they started from, not where they were exported to, and never mind that this is the opposite of the "creation story" commonly told in the Basenji community.
No matter. Myth and fantasy are important to all cultures, and that is as true in London, New York and Kansas City as it is in the Congo, Cairo, and Timbuktu. Not all dogs can be as well documented as the Kill-Devil Terrier, the Darwin Retriever, or the Shenandoah Mountain Cur.