Monday, November 16, 2026

Coffee, Newspapers, and What's Next



Some years back I wrote about the magical effect of the world's most openly traded and sold psychoactive drug:

With alcohol banned, coffee quickly became the "drug of choice" in the Arab world. While an alcohol-besotted Europe struggled in a drunken haze through the Dark Ages, the Arab world became caffeinated and invigorated. Soon after they started the first coffee houses in the world, Arabs began creating grand libraries, universities, new mathematical equations, and amazingly complex architectural designs. Such is the power of coffee.

Coffee houses hit Europe around 1600, and there they had the same effect they had in the Arab world -- a spectacular growth in intellectual clarity and output. From the enlightened coffee houses of London grew the first newspaper divisions (business, style, overseas news, etc.), the first organized scientific associations, and Lloyds of London --the first international insurance cartel.

With the division and collection of knowledge came newspaper sections, and then dedicated magazines, and eventually the internet.

But before there was the internet, there was The Whole Earth Catalogue.

Jonathan Markoff of The New York Times said The Whole Earth Catalog was "the Internet before the Internet. It was the book of the future. It was a web in newsprint."

Bingo.

This was the sum total of everything, as far as I was concerned.  No one beat the grandeur and scope and sheer energy of The Whole Earth Catalogue until the Internet came along. 

As Kevin Kelly, editor of Wired magazine and a former editor of The Whole Earth Catalog, has noted:

... it is no coincidence that The Whole Earth Catalogs disappeared as soon as the web and blogs arrived. Everything The Whole Earth Catalogs did, the web does better.

Which is true. The World Wide Web is far more comprehensive, far more beautiful in production, and far more interactive and participatory than The Whole Earth Catalogue could have ever hoped to be.

And yet this new thing, which has the capacity to foster community, connectivity, and interaction, is also chaotic, undisciplined, and sprawling.

Yes there's tons of information there, but there's also a lot of misinformation, rumor and outright lies. In many ways, it's like a massive restaurant bar or coffee house -- the very thing which sparked our first Great Information Age.

Apparently, I was not alone in noticing the parallel. 



Ha! There it is.

But where are we going with all this?

I am not sure, but one thing is for sure: We cannot stay where we are.

How many of us are now spending 4-, 6-, 8-, 12-, or even 18-hours a day reading and writing on computers, reading cell phones, and watching TV?

When are we going to fence up?

What started out as the World Wide Web is now the Wild Wild West.

Some are happy that this new electronic frontier remains unfenced, yet I cannot help but notice that in a world without fences we spend a lot of time chasing down once thing and chasing out another.

The internet, the cell phone and the television are consuming our lives. This cannot continue in this direction at this velocity. Something has to give.

What was great about The Whole Earth Catalog -- the internet before there was an Internet -- was that it had editors which sorted out the rot and imposed limits.

Sure these editors were dope-smoking, tie-dyed T-shirt wearing, volley-ball playing kids, but they were smart, hungry, curious, and open-minded. They were also skeptical not only of nonsense offered up by their parents generation, but also nonsense being offered up by their own. They were interested in tools to build a better house, a better car, a better farm, a better community, and a better world.

And they still are.

But the thing that they helped create -- the internet (and yes, Al Gore was very much its father!) -- is also a tool for mass distraction.

I note with some amusement that Stewart Brand, the creator of The Whole Earth Catalogue, has a pinned tweet on his Twitter feed: 

I will buckle down to work as soon as I finish reading the Internet.


Yep. Me too.
I completely get it.

So is there a point here?

Perhaps it is this: The internet makes it possible to not only re-use, re-cycle, and re-purpose stuff that we, and others, have written, but also to repair and correct things we got wrong 10, 20, or even 30 or more years ago.

Have you ever been wrong? 

I have -- quite a lot. I have spent years pursuing wrong or poorly framed ideas with too little appreciation for the complexity and subtlety of the divisions and gray areas.

For example, at age 17-22, I knew quite a lot about nuclear energy (I really did), but I did not fully appreciate or believe that production technology could improve and become safer, or that nuclear waste could be eliminated through subduction into the earth's core (already a nuclear hotbed). 

My thinking was simple:  How could we discount the crisis of the moment (nuclear proliferation and mounting waste) on the faith alone (religion!) that technological progress (unseen?) was going to bail us out,

It was madness I said. 

And it was. 

But, that said, I was still wrong -- the progress is indeed visible now, and perhaps it always has been.

So how am I going to to conclude this morning's disheveled ramble?  


Well good for them.

But, to be fair, Stewart Brand was revisiting his errors long before these yahoos were.  Stwart’s always been ahead of the curve, and he still is at age 87.

As for me, I am re-examining my relationship with coffee.  Black tea seems to propel me forward without as much internal wreckage.  It's also cheaper and has less calories (as I drink the tea plain, but the coffee with adulterations). 

Was I wrong about coffee too?   

No comments: